MIT OpenCourseWare http ocw mit edu CMS 608 CMS 864 Game Design Spring 2008 For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use visit http ocw mit edu terms Justin Moe CMS 608 2 25 2008 Note The following contents were excerpted from the journal of Dr Wallace Breen after recovery from the Citadel in City 17 Tablut Reconstruction Despite overseeing the perfection of humanity through its merger with the Combine and creating the Overwatch times come when an excursion into the treasure trove of the history of humanity becomes necessary for my own sanity Today with the help of Overwatch soldier 1 I experimented with recreating the game of Tablut It s a quite old game the documents describing it being from 1732 which is 279 years ago The rules are somewhat ill defined allowing some freedom in both interpretation and filling in gaps left in the rules The basic rules as interpreted from the 1732 description are as follows 1 The game requires two players 2 The game is played on a 9x9 grid It requires 16 pieces of one color 8 of another and a 9th king piece of the same color The initial setup is below the diagram is taken from Helmfrid 3 The object of the red team is to move the king piece located in the center to any of the edges where he escapes 4 The object of the blue team is to capture the king by surrounding him on all four sides 5 Red moves first with players taking alternating turns Moe 2 6 All pieces move an unlimited number of squares along a line similar to the rook or castle in chess 7 A piece is captured when it is surrounded on two opposite sides by enemy pieces one of which moved there by the movement of an enemy A piece is not captured when it moves between two enemy pieces since capture requires an enemy action These rules were the basis of my reconstruction but with several modifications arrived at via testing with Overwatch Soldier 1 Game Analysis Tablut is a game in the Tafl line of games One of the key distinguishing characteristics of Tafl games is the imbalance between the two players Masters In Tablut this is obvious by the numerical superiority of the blue or attacking team as compared to the red or defensive team The balance of Tafl games then becomes a more complex task since it requires balancing an asymmetrical game The balance of something like chess is relatively straightforward since both teams start with identical pieces in an identical arrangement on opposite sides of a square board The balance of an asymmetric game is much more challenging Moe 3 In examining the rules of Tablut it was obvious that there were certain ambiguities in the rules which would require clarification before play began It was also clear that certain rules would require either simplification or further explanation The rules while being relatively short and simple had a variety of complex consequences One example of unnecessary complexity was the behavior of the kings starting location and the starting location of the blue team These were both potentially considered hostile meaning players could not move through them or into them once they had moved out Another complexity was in the behavior of the escape rule for the king In particular when the king would be considered to have escaped was somewhat complex In the rules formulation it was stated that the king would escape via moving adjacent to any of the edges Helmfrid However if the blue team could surround the king on three sides in the following turn he would be captured instead This was another instance of complexity and could lead to situations where it was unclear which player was the winner or one player not realizing they could win because the other player had apparently satisfied their victory condition Rules Modifications The aim of the modification of the rules was two fold The first goal was a simplification of the rules removing unnecessary complexity from the game mechanics The second goal was maintaining or improving the balance of the game as a system Often multiple modifications were required some to reduce complexity and others to offset the balance changes that the simplifications caused The first game modification was the victory condition for the red team Their goal was simply to move the king to an edge of the board where he could escape from on the next turn There were certain limitations including whether or not the blue start areas sometimes referred to as base camps were accessible to red To simplify the game the base camps were made traversable by red This Moe 4 appeared to unbalance the game in favor of red since the area for the king to escape was approximately doubled To help restrict this an idea was taken from Alea Evangelii which was limiting the king s escape to only the four corners This helped to balance the game and also made it easier to discern when victory occurred for red since the escape points could be easily marked on the board To simplify the actual victory condition red would be victorious as soon as the king was moved onto one of the red corners In addition the four escape points are also hostile to all pieces This is done mainly to prevent blue from simply placing pieces in the four corners and making it essentially impossible for the king to escape This also opens up certain new strategies since they can be used by either red or blue for a piece in a capture and requires additional care in the corners While it is an added complexity the imbalance of allowing the camping of the escape points was a large enough problem to merit the added rule The second modification or more correctly clarification is the abilities of the king For balance the king is allowed to participate as one of two units in a capture This behavior is required to ensure that the red team has a reasonable ability to capture pieces when the king is moving and also for the sake of simplicity in the rules since it allows the king to behave almost entirely like any regular piece in the game The rule is only for clarification in the case of debate over the function of the king and would otherwise be an unstated consequence of the capture rule The final rules for my reconstruction of Tablut are as follows 1 The game requires two players 2 The game is played on a 9x9 grid It requires 16 pieces of one color 8 of another and a 9th king piece of the same color The initial setup is below Moe 5 3 The object of the red team is to move the king piece located in the center to any of the four marked corners where he