Systems I Code Optimization I Machine Independent Optimizations Topics Machine Independent Optimizations Code motion Reduction in strength Common subexpression sharing Tuning Identifying performance bottlenecks Great Reality There s more to performance than asymptotic complexity Constant factors matter too Easily see 10 1 performance range depending on how code is written Must optimize at multiple levels algorithm data representations procedures and loops Must understand system to optimize performance How programs are compiled and executed How to measure program performance and identify bottlenecks How to improve performance without destroying code modularity and generality 2 Optimizing Compilers Provide efficient mapping of program to machine register allocation code selection and ordering eliminating minor inefficiencies Don t usually improve asymptotic efficiency up to programmer to select best overall algorithm big O savings are often more important than constant factors but constant factors also matter Have difficulty overcoming optimization blockers potential memory aliasing potential procedure side effects 3 Limitations of Optimizing Compilers Operate Under Fundamental Constraint Must not cause any change in program behavior under any possible condition Often prevents it from making optimizations when would only affect behavior under pathological conditions Behavior that may be obvious to the programmer can be obfuscated by languages and coding styles e g data ranges may be more limited than variable types suggest Most analysis is performed only within procedures whole program analysis is too expensive in most cases Most analysis is based only on static information compiler has difficulty anticipating run time inputs When in doubt the compiler must be conservative 4 Machine Independent Optimizations Optimizations you should do regardless of processor compiler Code Motion Reduce frequency with which computation performed If it will always produce same result Especially moving code out of loop for i 0 i n i for j 0 j n j a n i j b j for i int ni for j a ni 0 i n i n i 0 j n j j b j 5 Compiler Generated Code Motion Most compilers do a good job with array code simple loop structures Code Generated by GCC for i int ni int p for j p for i 0 i n i for j 0 j n j a n i j b j imull ebx eax movl 8 ebp edi leal edi eax 4 edx Inner Loop movl 12 ebp edi L40 movl edi ecx 4 eax movl eax edx addl 4 edx incl ecx cmpl ebx ecx jl L40 0 i n i n i a ni 0 j n j b j i n a p a i n scaled by 4 b b j p p j loop scaled by 4 b j scaled by 4 if j n 6 Reduction in Strength Replace costly operation with simpler one Shift add instead of multiply or divide 16 x x 4 Utility machine dependent Depends on cost of multiply or divide instruction On Pentium II or III integer multiply only requires 4 CPU cycles Recognize sequence of products for i 0 i n i for j 0 j n j a n i j b j int ni 0 for i 0 i n i for j 0 j n j a ni j b j ni n 7 Make Use of Registers Reading and writing registers much faster than reading writing memory Limitation Compiler not always able to determine whether variable can be held in register Possibility of Aliasing See example later 8 Machine Independent Opts Cont Share Common Subexpressions Reuse portions of expressions Compilers often not very sophisticated in exploiting arithmetic properties Sum neighbors of i j up val i 1 n j down val i 1 n j left val i n j 1 right val i n j 1 sum up down left right 3 multiplications i n i 1 n i 1 n leal 1 edx ecx imull ebx ecx leal 1 edx eax imull ebx eax imull ebx edx int inj i n up val inj down val inj left val inj right val inj sum up down j n n 1 1 left right 1 multiplication i n i 1 i 1 n i 1 i 1 n i n 9 Time Scales Absolute Time Typically use nanoseconds 10 9 seconds Time scale of computer instructions Clock Cycles Most computers controlled by high frequency clock signal Typical Range 100 MHz 108 cycles per second Clock period 10ns 2 GHz 2 X 109 cycles per second Clock period 0 5ns 10 Example of Performance Measurement Loop unrolling Assume even number of elements void vsum1 int n int i for i 0 i n i c i a i b i void vsum2 int n int i for i 0 i n i 2 c i a i b i c i 1 a i 1 b i 1 11 Cycles Per Element Convenient way to express performance of program that operators on vectors or lists Length n T CPE n Overhead 1000 900 800 vsum1 Slope 4 0 700 Cycles 600 500 vsum2 Slope 3 5 400 300 200 100 0 0 50 100 150 200 Elements 12 Code Motion Example Procedure to Convert String to Lower Case void lower char s int i for i 0 i strlen s i if s i A s i Z s i A a 13 Lower Case Conversion Performance Time quadruples when string length doubles Quadratic performance lower1 1000 CPU Seconds 100 10 1 0 1 0 01 0 001 0 0001 256 512 1024 2048 4096 8192 16384 32768 65536 131072 262144 String Length 14 Convert Loop To Goto Form void lower char s int i 0 if i strlen s goto done loop if s i A s i Z s i A a i if i strlen s goto loop done strlen executed every iteration strlen linear in length of string Must scan string until finds 0 Overall performance is quadratic 15 Improving Performance void lower char s int i int len strlen s for i 0 i len i if s i A s i Z s i A a Move call to strlen outside of loop Since result does not change from one iteration to another Form of code motion 16 Lower Case Conversion Performance Time doubles when double string length Linear performance CPU Seconds 1000 100 10 1 0 1 0 01 0 001 0 0001 0 00001 0 000001 256 512 1024 2048 4096 8192 16384 32768 65536 131072 262144 String Length lower1 lower2 17 Optimization Blocker Procedure Calls Why couldn t the compiler move strlen out of the inner loop Procedure may have side effects Alters global state each time called Function may not return same value for given arguments Depends on other parts of global state Procedure lower could interact with strlen Why doesn t compiler look at code for strlen Linker may overload with different version Unless declared static Interprocedural optimization is not used extensively due to cost Warning Compiler treats procedure call as a black box Weak optimizations in and around them 18 Summary Today Improving program performance machine independent Mostly focusing on instruction count Next time Optimization blocker procedure calls Optimization blocker …