CHRISTINE JENNINGS, ELLENFEDDER, LANCE JONES, ERNESTLASCHE A/K/A/ MIKE LASCHE,BARBARA KLEIN, LOIS HARMES,JOHN MINDER, DOVIE MURRAY,JOHN McBRIDE, SUSAN GAAR,GARY LAMER, and CHARLESCLIFTON (COLLECTIVELY,"VOTER PLAINTIFFS" OR"PETITIONERS") ,Petitioners,v.ELECTIONS CANVASSINGCOMMISSION OF THE STATE OFFLORIDA; SARASOTA COUNTYCANVASSING BOARD; KATHYDENT, AS SARASOTA COUNTYSUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS; SUE M. COBB, AS SECRETARY OFTHE STATE TO FLORIDA; DAWNK. ROBERTS, AS DIRECTOR OFTHE DIVISION OF ELECTIONS OFTHE STATE OF FLORIDA; VERNBUCHANAN; and ELECTIONSYSTEMS & SOFTWARE, INC.,Respondents._____________________________/IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALFIRST DISTRICT, STATE OF FLORIDANOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TOFILE MOTION FOR REHEARING ANDDISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILEDCASE NO. 1D07-0011-2-Opinion filed June 18, 2007.Petition for Writ of Certiorari - Original Jurisdiction.Kendall Coffey, of Coffey & Wright, L.L.P., Miami; Mark Herron, of Messer,Caparello & Self, P.A., Tallahassee; and Donald B. Verrilli, Jr., Sam Hirsch, JessicaRing Amunson, of Jenner & Block, L.L.P., Washington, for Petitioner Jennings.Matthew J. Zimmerman, Electronic Frontier Foundation, San Francisco, California;Rebecca Harrison Steele & Zeina N. Salam, A.C.L.U. Foundation of Florida, Tampa;and Reginald J. Mitchell, P.F.A.W. Foundation, Tallahassee, for Joinder Petitioners.Peter Antonacci and Allen Winsor, of GrayRobinson, P.A., Tallahassee, forRespondents Kurt S. Browning, Amy K. Tuck, and Elections CanvassingCommission. Miguel A. DeGrandy & Stephen M. Cody, of Miguel DeGrandy, P.A.,Miami; and Harry O. Thomas & Jeffrey L. Frehn, of Radey, Thomas, Yon & Clark,Tallahassee, for Respondent Election Systems & Software, Inc. Glenn T. Burhans, Jr.,Hayden R. Dempsey & M. Hope Keating, of Greenberg Traurig, P.A., Tallahassee,for Respondent Vern Buchanan.BROWNING, C.J.The petitioners seek certiorari review of the trial court’s non-final order denyingmotions to compel discovery, including a request to order the respondents to disclosetrade secrets, including the source code and other proprietary technology associatedwith certain voting machines used in the Florida Thirteenth Congressional District inthe November 2006 election, which Petitioner Christine Jennings lost to Respondent-3-Vern Buchanan by fewer than 400 votes, according to the certified election results.We have jurisdiction. See Art. V, § (4)(b)(3), Fla. Const.; Fla. R. App. P.9.030(b)(2)(A). “We recognize that an order denying discovery is ordinarily notreviewable by certiorari because the harm from such orders, as a general rule, can berectified on plenary appeal.” Ruiz v. Steiner, 599 So. 2d 196, 197 (Fla. 3d DCA1992). This is such a situation. Because the petitioners have not met theirextraordinary burden to demonstrate that the trial court departed from the essentialrequirements of law, resulting in irreparable, material injury for the remaining trialproceedings that cannot be rectified on direct appeal, we deny the petition for writ ofcertiorari. See Martin-Johnson, Inc. v. Savage, 509 So. 2d 1097, 1099 (Fla. 1999);S.Y. v. McMillan, 563 So. 2d 807, 809 (Fla. 1st DCA 1990) (denying petition for writof certiorari, where petitioner failed to show that the trial court departed from “aclearly established principle of law resulting in a miscarriage of justice which cannotbe remedied on direct appeal”).PETITION FOR WRIT DENIED.POLSTON and HAWKES, JJ.,
View Full Document
Unlocking...