10 27 2010 NEWS Ground Zero Mosque Controversy Sh OPINION WASHINGTON WHISPERS CONGRESS TRACKER WHITE HOUSE TRACKER Ground Zero Mosque Controversy Shows America s New Nativism The proposed community center would enrage bin Laden so why are Sarah Palin and Newt Gingrich taking up his cause By ROBERT SC HLESINGER Posted August 11 2010 Have you heard about the ground zero mosque They re going to build a great towering monstrosity of a thing a gloating reminder of what they did to us on 9 11 a thumb in the eye of any real Americans who want to pay respect to those lost on that tragic day It will according to Rudy Giuliani be a desecration of ground zero Newt Gingrich has called it an assertion of Islamist triumphalism And Sarah Palin was so incensed at what she called a stab in the heart that she coined a new word calling on peaceful Muslims to refudiate the project Check out our editorial cartoons on the ground zero mosque controversy It s too bad they re wrong The debate over the so called ground zero mosque which is neither a mosque nor at ground zero is certainly a cause for anger and outrage But it s not because some Americans want to exercise their constitutionally guaranteed right to worship freely Rather it s troubling as an expression of a new Know Nothingism that is infecting our politics especially on the demagogic right The phrase ground zero mosque conjures images of a minaret adorned structure sprouting on or abutting ground zero But the truth is less provocative The project is sponsored by the Cordoba Initiative a group whose stated mission is to achieve an atmosphere of interfaith tolerance and respect among Muslims Christians and Jews The 100 million building they want to construct called Park51 for its address on Park Place is not a mosque as such but rather a community center with a restaurant a swimming pool a performing arts center and yes prayer space Muslims by the way already gather weekly in the existing building to pray Should they be barred from doing so And it s not at ground zero Park Place is a small street two blocks north of where the twin towers stood The intervening blocks have buildings taller than the planned center Someone standing at ground zero in other words would not be aware of Park51 s existence though when the Freedom Tower finally rises from the World Trade Center s footprints it will be visible throughout most of lower Manhattan and beyond Park51 will be just another building in what Mayor Michael Bloomberg a defender of the project called the diverse and dense city usnews com ground zero mosque 1 3 10 27 2010 Ground Zero Mosque Controversy Sh The symbolism of a Muslim community center being just another building in the shadow of the Freedom Tower is one we should embrace It speaks to our diversity and the strength of our ideals It s certainly more attractive than that of political leaders in the world s most powerful nation rallying to deny its most fundamental rights to a tiny minority Opponents say that Park51 s mere proximity to ground zero is an intentional political statement and it almost certainly is It says that not all Muslims are radical killers and thugs and that Islamic moderates won t be cowed into letting terrorists be the face of their religion Isn t that what we ve wanted Certainly it s a provocative message one that will incite rage in Osama bin Laden and his ilk Interfaith tolerance and respect are the last things on their agenda So why are the likes of Palin Gingrich and Giuliani taking up bin Laden s cause Perhaps because the distinction between the terrorists and the religion which George W Bush was so careful to make after 9 11 is no longer operative But it bears repeating The fact that all the 9 11 terrorists were Muslim does not make all Muslims terrorists any more than the fact that Ku Klux Klansmen are avowedly Christian makes all Christians white supremacists The problem isn t religion but fanaticism Indeed the Park51 debate is symptomatic of a new nativist fanaticism emerging in certain quarters of our politics You can also see it in Murfreesboro Tenn where plans for a Muslim community center or mosque as its critics call it were a hot issue in the Republican gubernatorial primary One candidate Lt Gov Ron Ramsey suggested that First Amendment protections for freedom of religion might not apply to Muslims Now you could even argue whether being a Muslim is actually a religion or is it a nationality way of life a cult whatever you want to call it he said in a campaign appearance a video of which was posted last month on YouTube And the trend is evident in recent calls to deal with a new phantom menace sharia or Islamic law Ramsey who placed a distant third in his primary Thursday also talked about the danger of sharia gaining power in this country It s an admittedly imbecilic fear but it s one shared by legislators in Oklahoma who will likely put on November s ballot a referendum pre emptively barring state courts from using sharia and in Iowa where the GOP party platform weighs in against any effort to implement it in this country This illusory threat has gained enough credence that Gingrich speaking at the American Enterprise Institute last month described it as a mortal threat to the survival of freedom in the United States And it s not just Muslims who demagogues are demonizing There s the hysteria over the supposed crime soaked tide of illegal immigrants pouring across the southern border and the federal response to illegal immigration Consider that violent crime rates in border states have declined in recent years and that this year the administration deported a record number of criminal aliens No matter This is the politics of fear not the politics of fact It s a politics that targets most simply they whether they re from a different faith or a different country They re everywhere usnews com ground zero mosque 2 3 10 27 2010 Ground Zero Mosque Controversy Sh even the president was born in Kenya we re told So be afraid and stay that way Check out a roundup of editorial cartoons on the ground zero mosque controversy Follow the money in Congress Become a political insider Subscribe to U S News Weekly our digital magazine C opyright 2010 U S Ne ws W orld R e port LP All rights re se rve d Use of this W e b site constitute s acce ptance of our Te rm s and Conditions of Use a nd P rivacy Policy usnews com ground zero mosque 3 3