Rice PHIL 307 - Characteristics of political obligation and authority

Unformatted text preview:

Characteristics of political obligation and authority (Consent Theory)1. In order for someone to have political authority there must be others obliged to follow that political authority. Poltical obligation and political authority arecorrelatives.2. To be under political obligation there must be a reason for a person to oblige themselves to the authority. But it is possible for one to have political obligationand yet be morally justified in disobeying the state.3. "Political Obligation" refers to a specific reason to obey the state not covered by just any reason such as promising a loved one to obey the state as that doesnot give the state the authority to govern over the person who made the promise as the promise is not based on political obligation.4. The existence of a political authority relationship is neither a sufficient nor necessary condition for political obligation.• If an individual is to agree to the rules of the state then that individual is also agreeing to an obligation to follow it's rules and authority• Churches are the same way, we implicitly agree to follow the rules and of the church• According to Beran giving consent is much the same as giving a promise and therefore when one gives consent to obey a state it is their moral duty toobligate themselves to following that consent• The Consent Theory does not seek to answer why should I obey any law, and questions such as this that deal with specificity dependent on one'scircumstances, but rather why should one obey authority to a state.• A group of people cannot have the authority to govern unless given consent, but they may be morally justified in exercising power without consent• According to David Hume, Consent Theorists ask and claim:1. Why are we bound by our government? and answer: Because...2. We have promised to obey our government3. and we are bound to keep our promises.4. Why should we keep our word? Because…5. It is necessary for civilized life• Hume argues that five is a sufficient answer to one and therefore we can bypass the morally objectifiable promise• But this argument only hits that obligation to the state is a necessity for civilized life, but does not handle that for some people that may not be the way oflife and does not answer why certain individuals should be morally obligated to the state. It is not in the utility of the state, because as illustrated in mybelow point in some sense the state is not necessary for individuals already upholding civilized life.• To further the argument, if the idea that we need government to maintain civilized life comes from the people under the government, then why do we needgovernment at all if those giving consent to be governed in order to have a civilized life already have in mind upholding a civilized life• The reason I believe this is so is because as people we are unsure as to whether others will uphold those same standards.Government serves as a moralequalizer.• Where it gets corrupt is where people leading the government lose their sense or morality that the people may have or have a warped sense of moralityover the people.• There are three ways in which an individual can avoid agreeing with the constitution of a state:• Secession• Migration• Public Declaration where one agrees to the constitution of the state• The only people morally bound to follow the constitution of a state are those in a position to make moral decisions. Morality is secondary to well-being andsurvival. Therefore in a state where not everyone's well-being is met. not everyone could be morally obligated to follow the rules of theconstitution because some (namely the poor) are not in a position to make choices based on morality. but these fall under the secondary reasons why oneshould not obey a state.• Peasants and the poor accept their membership in a state not by agreeing to be members, but rather by their ignorance and poverty in not knowing any


View Full Document

Rice PHIL 307 - Characteristics of political obligation and authority

Download Characteristics of political obligation and authority
Our administrator received your request to download this document. We will send you the file to your email shortly.
Loading Unlocking...
Login

Join to view Characteristics of political obligation and authority and access 3M+ class-specific study document.

or
We will never post anything without your permission.
Don't have an account?
Sign Up

Join to view Characteristics of political obligation and authority 2 2 and access 3M+ class-specific study document.

or

By creating an account you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use

Already a member?