Unformatted text preview:

Special topicsFixed effects When trying to compare apples with apples, we worry about the numerous potential differences on confounding variables If differences on confounding variables are stable over time, we can eliminate bias from them by only analyzing variation within the same unit over time E.g., breast-feeding study (unit is woman) E.g., currency unions and euro (unit is country) To only analyze variation within the same unit over time, we use fixed effects  Stata commands areg and xtreg Equivalent to adding indicator (or dummy variables) variables for units Equivalent to between subjects design (as opposed to within subjects)Intra-Country Variationxtreg [DV] [IV], fe(or)areg [DV] [IV], a(country)Inter-Country Variationxtreg [DV] [IV], be(or)collapse [DV] [IV], by(country)reg [DV] [IV]Aggregate Panel Variationreg [DV] [IV]Intra- or Inter-country Variation?(animated slide, see summary on next slide)DVIVIntra- or Inter-country Variation?DVIVAggregate Panel Variationreg [DV] [IV]DVIVFixed effects (fe)Intra-Country Variationxtreg [DV] [IV], fe(or) areg [DV] [IV], a(country)DVIVBetween effects (be)Inter-Country Variationxtreg [DV] [IV], be(or)collapse [DV] [IV], by(country)reg [DV] [IV]Fixed effects Problems Throws away potentially relevant variation (alternative: random effects) Variation over time may be primarily from random measurement error (e.g., unions and wages) Unusual factors may drive changes in explanatory variables over time and also influence the dependent variable (e.g., currency unions)InteractionsInteractions Interactions test whether the combination of variables affects the outcome differently than the sum of the main (or individual) effects. For example, how would we test whether defendants are sentenced to death more frequently for killing white strangers than you would expect from the coefficients on white victim and on victim stranger?. tab wv vs| vswv | 0 1 | Total-----------+----------------------+----------0 | 12 14 | 26 1 | 37 37 | 74 -----------+----------------------+----------Total | 49 51 | 100Interactions. g wvXvs = wv* vs. reg death bd yv ac fv v2 ms wv vs wvXvs -----------------------------------------------death | Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t|-------+---------------------------------------(omitted)wv | .0985493 .1873771 0.53 0.600vs | .1076086 .2004193 0.54 0.593wvXvs | .3303334 .2299526 1.44 0.154_cons | .0558568 .2150039 0.26 0.796-----------------------------------------------•To interpret interactions, substitute the appropriate values for each variable•E.g., what’s the effect for • .099 wv+.108 vs+.330 wvXvs •White, non-stranger: .099(1)+.108(0)+.330(1)*(0) = .099•White, stranger: .099(1)+.108(1)+.330(1)*(1) = .537•Black, non-stranger: .099(0)+.108(0)+.330(0)*(0) = comparison•Black, stranger: .099(0)+.108(1)+.330(1)*(0) = .108Interactions. tab wv vs, sum(death)Means, Standard Deviations and Frequencies of death| vswv | 0 1 | Total-----------+----------------------+----------0 | .16666667 .28571429 | .23076923| .38924947 .46880723 | .42966892| 12 14 | 26-----------+----------------------+----------1 | .40540541 .75675676 | .58108108| .49774265 .43495884 | .4967499| 37 37 | 74-----------+----------------------+----------Total | .34693878 .62745098 | .49| .48092881 .48829435 | .50241839| 49 51 | 100Importance of a variableDeath penalty example. sum death bd- yv Variable | Obs Mean Std. Dev. Min Max-------------+--------------------------------------------------------death | 100 .49 .5024184 0 1bd | 100 .53 .5016136 0 1wv | 100 .74 .440844 0 1ac | 100 .4366667 .225705 0 1fv | 100 .31 .4648232 0 1-------------+--------------------------------------------------------vs | 100 .51 .5024184 0 1v2 | 100 .14 .3487351 0 1ms | 100 .12 .3265986 0 1yv | 100 .08 .2726599 0 1Death penalty example. reg death bd-yv , beta------------------------------------------------death | Coef. Std. Err. P>|t| Beta-------+-----------------------------------------bd | -.0869168 .1102374 0.432 -.0867775wv | .3052246 .1207463 0.013 .2678175ac | .4071931 .2228501 0.071 .1829263fv | .0790273 .1061283 0.458 .0731138vs | .3563889 .101464 0.001 .3563889v2 | .0499414 .1394044 0.721 .0346649ms | .2836468 .1517671 0.065 .1843855yv | .050356 .1773002 0.777 .027328_cons | -.1189227 .1782999 0.506 .-------------------------------------------------Importance of a variable Three potential answers Theoretical importance Level importance Dispersion importanceImportance of a variable Theoretical importance Theoretical importance = Regression coefficient (b) To compare explanatory variables, put them on the same scale E.g., vary between 0 and 1Importance of a variable Level importance: most important in particular times and places E.g., did the economy or presidential popularity matter more in congressional races in 2006? Level importance= bj* xjImportance of a variable Dispersion importance: what explains the variance on the dependent variable E.g., given that the GOP won in this particular election, why did some people vote for them and others against? Dispersion importance =  Standardized coefficients, or alternatively Regression coefficient times standard deviation of explanatory variable In bivariate case, correlationWhich to use? Depends on the research question Usually theoretical importance Sometimes level importance Dispersion importance not usually relevantPartial residual scatter plotsPartial residual scatter plots Importance of plotting your data Importance of controls How do you plot your data after you’ve adjusted it for control variables? Example: inferences about candidates in Mexico from facesGreatest competence disparity: pairing 10A B Gubernatorial race  A more


View Full Document

MIT 17 871 - Special Topics

Documents in this Course
Load more
Download Special Topics
Our administrator received your request to download this document. We will send you the file to your email shortly.
Loading Unlocking...
Login

Join to view Special Topics and access 3M+ class-specific study document.

or
We will never post anything without your permission.
Don't have an account?
Sign Up

Join to view Special Topics 2 2 and access 3M+ class-specific study document.

or

By creating an account you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use

Already a member?