2.009 Product engineering processes!"life is not a dress!rehearsal!Rose Tremain, author2.009 Product engineering processes!Today!"Review feedback learn and keep improving"Tomb raiding! testing ideas!!But first!Some logistics"Think ahead to the next milestone, wait for feedback "by Tuesday AM)!"Microcontroller tutorial today 5 PM in Pappalardo!!Peer review 1 is due 9 PM Wednesday!"Team review A is due 9 PM Wednesday"!Feedback: sketch review!What’s the point?"A motivational target, manage timeline, typical milestone!Summarize exploration of the design space"Buy in from real, tangible customer or expert"Identify additional challenges early, hear different viewpoints!(more feedback over weekend)"Discover what you don’t know"Practice early design exploration strategies and presentation techniques!"Grading?!Learn, do it for real, and grades will take care of themselves!Feedback: sketch model phase!Objectives"Develop a deeper understanding of the problem/opportunity context "(e.g., market, benchmarking, patents)!!Identify the top few user/purchaser needs!!Preliminary exploration and feasibility assessment of ways to address needs, and to address key risks or unknowns!!Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!memorable: !!Purple A: eDrum"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!memorable: !!Green A: In-fence"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!memorable: !!Silver A: Habitus"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!memorable: !!Pink B: IceCheck"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!product vision: !!orange b: coach"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!best hat: !!pink "Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!! !graphic design: !!orange a: ruma"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!! !exploration: !!red a: transVend "silver a: imagilimb "green b: dry-venture "Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!user needs/experience: !!yellow a: the X"an adventure is…?!!Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!benchmarking: !!blue b : flowAssist"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!experiments: !!blue b : flowAssist"Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!good use of model: !!blue b: hand hero"communication "!Feedback: sketch model phase!some good examples!!!honest: !!green a: TreeFort"Constructive feedback!put the following discussion in context"name a team characteristic that has negative correlation with success!excessive praise!"Feedback: general!reflection"Presentation design and practice is important:!Who saw presentations that showed signs of insufficient design or practice?!Who feels that their section did not prepare enough?!(4 sections went over time, pick your core message and get it out, plan your physical setup. Several third presenters were left short)!!Working with a purpose is important:!Who saw models that seemed to provide little additional information?!Who feels that their team’s models provided little additional information?!(physical models that allow realistic testing or experiments are useful, form models need to be well resolved to be useful, have clarity in purpose)!Feedback: sketch model phase!reflection!!!model providing little information: !!silver a: letMilk"Feedback: sketch model phase!reflection!!!remote gesticulation: !!green a: treeFort (and many more)"Feedback: general!reflection"test in advance""practice with the remote!""demo the product up front!""work with real users (blue a: sponge assure)!!don’t undersell your design thinking, models"Rankings!Faculty average"2 hours of discussion. 23 course staff and mentors!Use to reflect upon what worked "well, what did not.!!Not a grade. !It is the first impression to a group of people versed in the discipline.!!Ideas with lots of potential may have not ranked as highly do to mix of factors, and vice versa.!!Idea-specific feedback over the next few days. !!!!!Ranking!Faculty average"2 hours of discussion. 23 course staff and mentors!Use to reflect upon what worked "well, what did not.!!Not a grade. !It is the first impression to a group of people versed in the discipline.!!Ideas with lots of potential may have not ranked as highly do to mix of factors, and vice versa.!!Idea-specific feedback over the next few days. !!!!!Build Challenge!!Tomb raiders"!!"!be the fastest team to retrieve the gems and treasure from the fabled tomb"or have the most spirited team!Build challenge!!Quick synopsis"!!"!use your human-powered 2 person vehicle to travel to the fabled tomb (no feet)""""!!retrieve the 13 gemstones one-at-a-time, and finally the treasure chest (no bare hands)!!while having fun!!The challenge!Quick synopsis"!!"!all willing team members will cycle through riding the vehicle over several laps to retrieve all gemstones and treasure.!!vehicles line up at start, each vehicle has two people. !!vehicles go in straight lines.!!yellow is a bit different, as the first two will need to lay out the islands, and then carry one stone back (using protective gloves and passing the stone between each other over the pads). Then two more run out.!The challenge!Quick synopsis"on the last lap, when all gems have been retrieved, the last crew retrieve the treasure along with a team flag back to start point behind their vehicle.!!when they arrive back at the starting point, the flag is run to the holder at the top of Killian to finish the race.!Logistics!activity!"go to your team’s start area (put on raiding hats)"choose your crews and running order !(numbered stickers, wear multiple stickers if you have more than one lap)!start / team area!Logistics!activity!"stay in your team area unless operating vehicle""start / team area!Logistics!activity!"stay in your team area unless operating vehicle""start / team area!Logistics!relay race!"have each crew practice operating vehicle!!be aware of potential pinch points and how your motions affect your fellow driver!stay close to the start area!facilitator will help, 5 minutes for practice!Logistics!relay race!"and remember…"you have pompoms to cheer"Logistics!relay race!"race begins on pistol shot, first crew advances through lava towards tombs"facilitator will travel with you (wearing protective booties)!Logistics!relay race!"When machines get close enough to the tomb, riders either use rake to gather gemstones, or gloves if they have hot mitts.!feet cannot touch the ground so people must stay in vehicle!Logistics!activity!"Vehicle is ridden back with the stone to